I have never been able to fit in with the School Gates Mothers (SGMs). Any type. There are many, but all appear to fit into three categories. The first wear tracksuit bottoms that have more unidentified stains than a youth hostel’s upholstery and look at me as if I’m too posh to understand their predicament; the second are the impossibly thin ones with high-lighted short hair – sports hair – that come to school in tracksuit bottoms that would sound an alarm at any stain other than spirulina-infused sweat (my love-handles have love-handles, which tells them I’ve clearly let myself go); and the third are those who look suburb-come-place of worship. I think they look at me and see a dangerous – possibly contagious – instability.
All of them, cruelly grouped by attire and I apologise, probably see a woman, still dressing as if she were a twenty-something ‘70s throwback in jeans and geometrical-print top, and decide they are simply not going to take her seriously. Not at least until she can purchase lady-fit jeans from a reputable department store that refuse to flare or ride below the tropic of naval. I’ll never do that. Never. And you know what? I don’t want to be taken seriously. Nattering and pinching invisible dust from their knees like dexterous hens isn’t my thing. If only one of them would lean against something, dressed en vogue smoking a fag (I gave up long ago but admire anyone who still does it in the face of slit-wrist health warnings and the even more petrifying mums-who-smoke-choke brigade) or sit cross-legged on the floor – I hate all this thrombosis-forming knee-crossing (leg up and over aaaand swap, repeat ad child-pickup-um); and those hunched backs where you sometimes see the spine-knuckles protruding as they lean across each other or scratch an ankle; then there’s the pushing back up the nose of sunglasses, the tucking of hair behind ears... It’s impossible to explain how my own anthropological study of SGMs has frenzied me to the point where I dread school chuck-out at 3.30pm. But it could be because I anticipate standing alone at the edge of coop like those ostracised chickens you see with no feathers on their necks, socially conditioned to believe I should try to interact, too insecure to do it with any conviction, but self-bullied into making an attempt but bucking like a kid faced with a filthy bedroom and an ultimatum. They must think she’s weird.
Occasionally an SGM will take pity and sidle over with a how are you? and a how’s yours settling in? and I should be grateful for the lifeline, but I look into her eyes and see Mummy’s To Do list on the fridge, Tupperware catalogues on her kitchen counter, compartmentalised sewing set in her closet... and I’d rather eat my own eyeballs than give a reply that would encourage any intimacy. Frankly I’m intimidated but the overly-organised. They seem too in control. Like a domestic Gestapo – getting the school forms back in time, volunteering to oversee playground recreation, making parent-contribution rosters, sneering when I ask if anyone knows when parent-teacher evening is (it was last week). And maybe I’ve yet to tap in to the joys of being ‘fully involved’, but to me it’s all a bit of a replacement for life. Not that I do anything more life-fulfilling instead. But I keep the time free in case something should come along.
Who knows, perhaps these mums go home to bonk the gardener senseless in between writing chapters of Marlow’s biography. “You won’t know if you don’t give it time,” my husband tells me. “It takes time to get to know someone.” Well, I’m nearing forty. I don’t have time to invest in small talk only to find out age 42 that there isn’t another side to Jane Smallsby, mother of Chloe and wife of Roger; and her impossibly bouncy bob is actually the liveliest thing about her. I might be wrong. I may well strike upon a bob-cut housing a wild-cat, another mum who thinks G&C (gin and cranberry, for you conformists) isn’t a sin, but a rather nice way of letting life’s aches and pains slip under the table and out of sight. Or someone who, in rare bouts of parenting bliss, rips Patsy Biscoe from the tape deck and cajoles the kids into a kitchen striptease-ercise to Grease’s You’re The One That I Want. Like I do, obviously... I can’t take the risk. If a mum isn’t going to wear her more piquant personality on her sleeve I have to let her go. Although, to be contrary, I would find someone who bombarded me with their misunderstood fetishes or personal hygiene issues at first sitting a tad alarming. I suppose the school gate ritual could be the mask that hides the more interesting underbelly, reserved for good friends. It’s a deportment that should be applauded, if so. I’m far too spill-the-beansish.
My deep discomfort, I’m sure a psychologist would tell me with a pitying nod and a hand on the knee, is because I think they are good parents and believe myself to be a very very bad one (pressed lips, knitted brow, nod, nod). She would be right. Doesn’t make me like them, though. And here is the primary reason why I hate SGMs for making me feel bad about myself: SGMs talk about their children all the time.
ALL THE TIME. Like there was no one, no subject that could lure away their thoughts or tear their mouths and minds from the most important job in the world. And it is the most important job in the world. But even barristers need to stop asking questions, even baristas need to stop drinking coffee, just sometimes. That’s my self-defence. I guess I should get a lawyer. I don’t talk about my children ever, unless prompted – me? Oh I have two of them, oh yes, very close together, I’m certifiable you know – or unless it’s to fill a conversational lull so dangerously expanding it feels like verbal ground is falling away and my lips will be soon sucked into anti-matter and I’ll never speak again. Oh my god, say something – okay – er – how old is yours? And it comes out through a mouth that must look as if it’s retrieving a stone from an olive, and my eyes, however hard I try to focus them on Jane Smallsby’s lips or chin or eyes, refuse to play, darting away guiltily. And she’ll think she’s weird.
There’s nothing to even indicate that an SGM may be finding the conversation a little repetitive, despite meeting at the school gates twice a day, every day, for most of the year. Upon year. They roll their eyes and tut, but not in ennui. Cleverly disguised as aural devotion to the speaker, it’s actually a gap-filler, something to do while another SGM is talking to hold back their own desperation to discuss the most important job on earth, according to them. I don’t feel that way. Ergo, surely, I am a bad mother. There are few other chances to discuss the most important job on earth – and much like the smoking room in an office building, when there were such things, this is the parents’ place. A place to bitch about the job. And they do. Goodness, it’s like watching World’s Finest Wrestling. The punches are there – “Pippa drives me nuts” – and the headlocks – “If Toby pinches his sister one more time, I don’t know what I’ll do” – and the knock-outs – “That’s it, I said, no more chocolate”... but you know it’s for show. A pantomime of huffs and puffs. You know without the head-shaking and the sharp intakes of air the most important job in the world would seem too easy. Fair dinkum – but they’re hardly making it sound bad enough. They swat away at childrearing topics as you would a fly.
Look, I know these mums have the same issues as I do; I know they just water it down to retain dignity, limiting school gate conversation to sleep patterns and minor tantrums. I understand their opaque personalities are probably parental burkhas donned for drop-off and pick-up. And I’m not saying it’s not hard. Quite the contrary.
It’s really hard. But I’m so traumatised by how hard it is I can barely speak. I can’t tattle about my daughter’s tantrum and not tell the full story. It will gather momentum. It’ll start as a tsk-tut tale of her reaction to some late-in-the-day discipline, but before I know it I’ll be verbally vomiting the full sorry story, how I was pushed to the edge and screamed till I went blue, till my daughter was scared of me and cried for daddy; it’s like ripping open wounds. If I met a mum who, after a particularly grotesque account of my failings to cope, said shit, that is bad, I might feel momentarily anaesthetised by her honesty, I may even giggle. Or if one said you know what, I have a secret way of dealing with that – come round to mine with a bottle and I’ll give you the spell – well, I’d be anaesthetised, possibly inebriated, and on my way to thinking no biggie, really. But experience has taught me that opening up a wound to the average SGM will not be met by first aid. It will be met by the following words: Well, I... And while the SGM interrupts to explain why she has a particular issue (not dissimilar to yours, but really, given the differences in family dynamic really not on the same page and anyway if you could just finish what you were saying...) – your wound is left open and bleeding. There’s been no closure and nobody cares. And it bleeds all the way home, leaving you weak, wobbly and primed to snap at your children, whatever it is they want. But we only wanted you to play Snakes & Ladders with us! And then you realise by the sad, orphan-esque looks on their faces that snarling at tries to make you a happy mummy might have scarred them for life. That’s why I don’t talk about parenting. Unless of course in the company where bad parenting is a badge of honour, and I can then go home with a hypocritical smirk, thinking ooh, they’re not very good parents, are they? and feel much better about myself. I might even think they’re weird.
I suppose I should give an alternative scenario, present you with a school gate scene that would make me happy. Here’s one: everyone arrives to pick up their children with a good book. The silence would be golden, you’d get in some reading time, and if there were to be a high-spirited mood in the air, one where conversation would be a good accompaniment, we could ask each other what we were reading. Not only would we avoid the agonising repetition of naughty-Johnny stories, but we can ascertain at a glance which of us might possibly be on the same page. Had I known Jane Smallsby was into the literary equivalent of a Hallmark card before she took pity and came and sat next to me and proceeded to roll her tongue around the most tedious of topics while pinning me with her bulging blues, I would have said sorry, this seat’s taken – by my bag. (Being offensive always saves time). And I have done that, the book thing. I have turned up to school and buried my nose in a book – I even made sure it didn’t have too snooty a cover; but did anyone crane to see the title or ask what I was reading? No. They looked at each other, and without moving, swung their eyeballs my way and back again. It’s a common high school manoeuvre. And it means she’s weird.
Maybe there are schools out there where mums are drawn to ice-breakers other than child-rearing – where they do ask what each other are reading, or say hey, has anyone managed to see Bill Nihy’s new film?, or start a Top-Ten conversation or comment on your tattoo. I don’t have one, but if I did I’m sure I’d like people to comment on it.
Maybe I just send my kids to the wrong school. They’re happy there. But given that I’m not, and it’s my happiness we’re talking about here, I should probably seek out a catchment that scoops up the more unhinged, who are bound to have less Gestapo-like mothers. Hey, it’s possible that they may be introduced to drugs earlier than I’d hope and encouraged in the skills of kleptomania – but what doesn’t kill them makes them stronger, right? And maybe, apart from when there’s an odd official-sounding knock at the door, I won’t have sweaty palms.
Post Script: I recently decided to join in. I fluffed up what feathers remain on my neck and de-ostracised myself. I began with hello and then did what they do – I clicked my tongue, rolled my eyes, emphasised my understanding with goggle-eyed intensity and butted in when I thought I had something to offer, or a story that was much better that theirs. Well, when in Rome... And you know, it was okay. I wasn’t knackered for once, I didn’t feel stressed as I normally do by the thud of time passing as you digest aural tripe. I was happy to chit-chat and ankle-scratch, and we actually got through child talk and onto something else before the mum realised suddenly she was wobbling in unchartered school gate talk and reached for a line about eating greens to steady herself. But I won’t be doing it every day. It’s a bit like having your hair done. It feels good and you can put up with salon selective conversation once every few months. But having it done every day? Well, anyone would start to feel a bit short, wouldn’t they?